4.6 from 7 reviews
Leave a Review

You've bought this product 0 times.

You've bought from this vendor 0 times.

Indian Creek Creamery

Whole Milk, Pasteurized, Non-homogenized

Dairy Products: Milk

Our cream line whole milk comes in a half-gallon (64 fluid ounces). The milk is minimally processed and as fresh as it gets. The milk is non-homogenized, high temperature/short time pasteurized and goes from the cow to the bottle the same day on our family farm in western Ohio. Because it is non-homogenized, the cream rises to the top, so if you don't want to skim the cream off the top for your coffee or other purposes, please be sure to SHAKE WELL to distribute the cream through the milk to enjoy the rich, creamy taste of milk as nature intended! USA / Ohio / Logan County

Sorry, this product is unavailable in your local market at this time. It is available in the following markets:
  • IND-Thursday
  • DCB-testMarket
  • Michiana
  • You must login or register to ask questions in the product forum.
    Q: What kind of dairy cows do you raise? Love your milk!

    A: Thank you so much for your encouraging message:) We milk mostly Holsteins with some Guernsey and Jersey cows in the mix, too.

    November 29th, 2019 person_outline Cathleen W.
    Q: I was speaking to my 85-year-old neighbor last night and she hadn’t heard of the fact that she could get milk almost like she used to when she was a kid. My concern is I don’t think you could handle the half gallon and be able to shake it and open it, do you possibly sell courts? Or do you have any suggestions as to what I can do so I don’t pour all of the cream of the very top and be able to make me to split a half a gallon with her? Thank you.

    A: If you shake the bottle very well, the cream should be distributed evenly throughout the bottle and then you could split a bottle. We almost always use ours completely shaken in at home:) We have found that laying the bottle on its side for a while makes it easier to shake the cream in sometimes. Hope this helps!

    November 12th, 2019 person_outline Melody L A.
    Q: What kind of shelf life can I expect from milk this fresh?

    A: We have a "Best Buy" date of 3 weeks. Of course, with non-homogenized milk the cream rises to the top and over the course of the 3 weeks the cream will become a little harder to "shake in" unless you shake it regularly...this does not affect the taste of the milk, however.

    August 18th, 2019 person_outline Nathan G.
    Q: Why has price it increased much in 1 week?

    A: We were running a special on our milk on Market Wagon.

    August 18th, 2019 person_outline Vanessa S.
    Q: What is the plastic bottle made of?

    A: Our bottles are made of 100% BPA free plastic.

    July 26th, 2019 person_outline Vanessa S.
    Q: Why did I pay less to n my first order and $3 more on my next order?

    A: Market Wagon was running a 30% off special on our milk.

    July 19th, 2019 person_outline Vanessa S.
    Q: What is the plastic bottle made of? Would you be able to provide with glass if I order regularly?

    A: We use a BPA free plastic bottle. At this time, we are not considering offering our milk in glass bottles.

    June 4th, 2019 person_outline Vanessa S.
    Q: Is there any way to get a pint of heavy whipping cream to make crepe fraiche that isn’t ultra pasturized?

    A: Thanks for the question. Unfortunately at this time we do not sell heavy cream separate - all of our cream stays in our milk. Our milk is not ultra pasteurized, though, instead it is pasteurized using the high temperature short time method to keep our milk as close to “straight from the cow” as possible.

    July 9th, 2020 person_outline Judy D.
    Q: What is delivery time on milk to evansville Indiana

    A: Thanks for reaching out! Unfortunately, I can not give you an exact time as the farmer, Market Wagon takes care of the deliver for us, so that would be a question for their staff.

    July 9th, 2020 person_outline Kenneth G.
    Q: antibiotic free and hormone free?

    A: Yes, our milk is as natural as can be with nothing added, no hormones or antibiotics.

    July 9th, 2020 person_outline Linda R.
    Q: Is this organic? Grass fed cows?

    A: Our milk is not organic. The cows do have pasture access everyday the weather permits. A majority of their diet is forages with only a small percent of their diet being grain to meet their energy demands. Our cows even have their own nutritionist that balances their daily ration to make sure all of their requirements are met.

    July 9th, 2020 person_outline Stefanie H.
    star star star star star

    format_quoteI received my 1st order this past Wednesday and the milk is out of this world. I always had a real tough time digesting milk, the Non -Homogenized is soooo goooood!!!! What a treat and I am so THANKFUL for coming across you guys with Market Wagon!! Now this will be my 2nd order and the milk is on sale (score) do you put it on special a lot? Very happy thanks again! Tim O. format_quote

    November 29th, 2019 person_outline Tim O.
    star star star star star

    format_quoteI love this milk and purchase it regularly. It is delicious.format_quote

    November 12th, 2019 person_outline Dan B.
    star star star star star

    format_quoteLove the taste of this milk. Creamy and delicious!format_quote

    August 18th, 2019 person_outline Michele C.
    star star star_outline star_outline star_outline

    format_quoteSpoiled the next day. format_quote

    August 18th, 2019 person_outline Michelle J.
    star star star star star

    format_quoteReally delicious milk. format_quote

    July 26th, 2019 person_outline Jim S.
    star star star star star

    format_quoteGreat milk. Wished it didn’t come in plastic bottles. I have asked the owner several times what plastic the bottle is made with no response :(. Also it won’t let me select less than 5 star rating 👀format_quote

    July 19th, 2019 person_outline Vanessa S.
    star star star star star

    format_quoteGreat tasting milk! I’ll take this replacement over store bought anytime!format_quote

    June 4th, 2019 person_outline Nicole C.

    Showing Products Similar To Whole Milk, Pasteurized, Non-homogenized